Argile verte

Has kaolin and a second clay (argilla) like the original, but lacks montmorillonite/illite and adds oils, silicones, fragrance and colorants not in the simple Cattier formula.

Contains both kaolin and montmorillonite like the source, but illite is missing and charcoal, talc, and many extra polymers/oils dilute the clay concentration and change the formula purpose.

Shares montmorillonite clay but misses kaolin and illite, and is loaded with essential oils, fragrance and polymers that change the profile entirely.

Only kaolin matches; montmorillonite and illite are missing, and the formula leans on oils, charcoal and salicylic acid rather than the original's clay trio.

Only kaolin overlaps; montmorillonite and illite are absent, and zinc PCA plus fragrance make it a different-purpose clay mask.