Peeling Gel 3in1 Fresh

Matches both hero actives, niacinamide and salicylic acid, but the delivery is a rice-based powder scrub rather than a gel, and lacks menthol's cooling effect.

Shares salicylic acid and menthol for a similar cooling/exfoliating feel, but is missing the niacinamide and adds sulfates not in the original.

It has salicylic acid for exfoliation but lacks niacinamide entirely, and uses plastic microbeads (acrylates crosspolymer) instead of pumice/silica.

Shares salicylic acid for exfoliation but has no niacinamide and relies on synthetic beads and parabens rather than the original's mineral exfoliants.

Only overlap is salicylic acid; no niacinamide, no menthol, and a much shorter, simpler formula overall.