masque argile

Shares peppermint extract and lactic acid but uses silica instead of kaolin/illite clay as its base, so the core clay-detox mechanism is missing.

This is a hair scalp treatment built on different clays (montmorillonite, moroccan lava clay) plus silicones, not the kaolin/illite clay mask base of Cattier, and it adds fragrance allergens the original lacks.

This is a silicone/conditioning hair mask with no clay at all, only coincidentally sharing lactic acid as a pH adjuster, so it doesn't replicate the clay-based detox function of Cattier's mask.

A coconut oil and conditioning agent-based hair mask with no clay ingredients; lactic acid overlap is incidental (pH adjuster only).

Coconut oil/behentrimonium-based hydrating hair mask with no clay, sharing only lactic acid as a minor pH adjuster, so it doesn't replicate Cattier's clay-purifying action.