Solid Cleansing Oil

Boscia does carry camellia sinensis and some plant extracts giving it the highest overlap of the group, but it's missing Erborian's core Asian herbal actives (licorice, scutellaria, ophiopogon, polygonum) and uses a different oil/emulsifier system.

Both are oil/balm cleansers but Elemis skips the Erborian's herbal complex (centella, licorice, scutellaria, houttuynia-type extracts) and its surfactant/wax base, only overlapping on trace tocopherol and camellia sinensis.

Same story as the other Elemis balm: nice oils and wax but none of Erborian's signature botanical actives (licorice, scutellaria, centella) and a totally different cleansing mechanism.

This is more an AHA exfoliating balm than a makeup remover; it shares only incidental tocopherol/camellia and adds acids not present in Erborian, missing all the calming herbal actives.

This is a citrus-oil cleansing/exfoliating product with rice extracts and synthetic dyes; it shares essentially nothing meaningful with Erborian's herbal-calming actives beyond trace tocopherol.