Kiehl's Calendula Herbal Extract Alcohol-Free Toner

This swaps calendula for green tea water and has no bisabolol or sodium PCA, so the calming/soothing profile is different even though both are lightweight hydrating toners.

Uses witch hazel and aloe as the soothing base rather than calendula and bisabolol, so it's a different actives profile despite similar humectant support.

Built around honey, propolis and botanical oils instead of calendula and bisabolol, so the core soothing actives don't match despite a similar humectant base.

This is a rose-water based toner with no calendula extract or bisabolol, so the key calming actives don't line up even though texture and format are similar.

Formulated around jasmine and citrus flower extracts with added dye and fragrance, missing calendula, bisabolol, and hyaluronate entirely.