Matte Lipstick

Near-identical wax/emollient base (octyldodecanol, bis-diglyceryl polyacyladipate-2, polyethylene, ozokerite, candelilla, beeswax) with titanium dioxide and iron oxides for color, so texture and finish should feel very close.

Shares the core emollient/wax skeleton (octyldodecanol, polyethylene, bis-diglyceryl polyacyladipate-2) and titanium dioxide/iron oxide pigments, but swaps beeswax for synthetic beeswax and adds silica and VP/hexadecene copolymer that change texture.

This is another MAC lipstick but a different formula line entirely, sharing only titanium dioxide and iron oxides as actives while using castor oil, paraffin, carnauba wax and a totally different colorant system instead of the source's wax blend.

It's a lip liner, not a lipstick, and while it shares polyethylene, ozokerite, titanium dioxide and iron oxides, it lacks the candelilla/beeswax/microcrystalline wax trio that gives MAC's matte lipstick its specific texture.

Completely different formulation built on lanolin, petrolatum, and mica/pearl pigments rather than the wax-and-lake-dye system MAC uses, with zero meaningful active overlap.