Le Wrap Exfolys

Shares the antioxidant trio (tocopherol, ascorbyl palmitate, ascorbic acid) and citric acid, but it's a sugar-based (sucrose) exfoliating cream with no rice starch, saccharide isomerate, or bisabolol, so the actual exfoliating and soothing actives don't match.

Shares tocopherol and citric acid plus a similar oil-in-water base with glyceryl stearate/stearic acid, but has no rice starch exfoliant, no saccharide isomerate, and no bisabolol/lily calming complex — it's argan-oil focused rather than an actives-matched exfoliant.

This is a walnut shell physical scrub with vitamin derivatives (ascorbyl palmitate/ascorbic acid overlap only), but it lacks the rice starch, saccharide isomerate, and bisabolol/lily soothing system that define the source formula, plus it adds harsh SLS and a dye.

A foot scrub using pumice for exfoliation and shea butter/aloe for care — only citric acid overlaps, missing the rice starch, saccharide isomerate, and bisabolol/lily system central to the source.

This is a lactic/polylactic acid chemical exfoliant, totally different mechanism from the source's rice starch physical scrub plus saccharide isomerate/bisabolol soothing complex; only citric acid overlaps as a minor pH adjuster.