LIFTACTIV SUPREME - Peaux normales à mixte

Shares caffeine but Vichy's real hero actives are adenosine, DMTT (neohesperidin dihydrochalcone) and the ammonium taurate film-former for firming/lifting, none of which appear here; Garnier leans on niacinamide and ascorbyl glucoside for brightening instead, a different mechanism.

Caffeine is present for de-puffing, but this is a hydrating/protein-based formula (hydrolyzed proteins, hyaluronate, vitamin C ester) with no adenosine or DMTT, so it targets puffiness/hydration rather than Vichy's firming/anti-glycation claims.

Only caffeine overlaps meaningfully; Yves Rocher is built around plant extracts (apple, aphloia, sea buckthorn) rather than Vichy's adenosine, DMTT, and silicone-based firming film, so the lifting mechanism isn't replicated.

Caffeine is shared for de-puffing, but Origins relies on ginseng, algae extracts, and niacinamide for brightening/energizing rather than Vichy's adenosine and DMTT firming actives.

No caffeine, adenosine, or DMTT at all; only trace overlap is citric acid (a pH adjuster, not an active), so this doesn't replicate Vichy's key firming/anti-fatigue actives.