Baume Lavant Réconfortant Peaux Extra Sèches

This is a true soap (saponified oils) sharing sunflower seed oil and tocopheryl acetate with the source, but lacks shea butter, aloe, and the surfactant/emulsifier system that gives the original its balm-cleanser feel.

Both are creamy sulfate-based washes with sodium cocoamphoacetate, but the source's sunflower oil/shea butter emollient base and ammonium lauryl sulfate are absent here, replaced by sodium laureth sulfate and glucoside surfactants.

Shares sodium cocoamphoacetate and aloe juice but is a foaming gel wash built on glutamate/sulfoacetate surfactants, missing the oil-and-shea-butter rich emollient base that defines the source's 'baume' texture.

Shares sodium cocoamphoacetate and aloe vera but is a mild glucoside-based foaming mousse without any oil or shea butter emollient, so it won't feel or perform like the balm-style source cleanser.

This jelly cleanser uses cocamidopropyl betaine and coco-glucoside with marula oil, sharing only aloe juice and tocopherol with the source, missing the sulfate cleanser and shea butter/sunflower oil base entirely.