Lotion tonique fraîcheur

Shares salicylic acid and the citric/lactic acid pH-adjusting trio, but Pixi adds glycolic acid and a ferment/hyaluronic acid complex that changes the exfoliation intensity and hydration profile versus Cien's calmer panthenol-silk formula.

Both contain salicylic acid plus alcohol denat, but Cien's low-key panthenol/silk soothing base is replaced here by a big herbal extract blend, so the feel and focus differ despite the shared BHA.

Only real overlap is salicylic acid and alcohol denat; La Roche-Posay skips the panthenol, hydrolyzed silk, and betaine that give Cien its soothing character, going for a more minimalist zinc/capryloyl glycine acne focus instead.

Shares salicylic acid and alcohol denat but pivots to thyme oil and menthol as the star actives, missing Cien's panthenol, hydrolyzed silk, and lotus extract entirely.

Only salicylic acid is shared; this is a fruit-extract/PHA-BHA toner with a totally different ingredient list, missing alcohol denat, panthenol, betaine, and the silk protein that define Cien's formula.