Clarity Tonic

Matches on glycolic acid as the main exfoliant (likely similar 5-7% strength), but has no salicylic acid, no hyaluronic acid, and swaps Pixi's soothing actives (licorice, centella, willow bark) for amino acids and ginseng.

Has salicylic acid but glycolic/lactic acid are trace (from a botanical-heavy herbal blend, not dosed as exfoliants), and it lacks Pixi's hyaluronic acid, licorice, and centella actives.

Shares salicylic and lactic acid but at unspecified/likely low concentration, and lacks glycolic acid's exfoliating power plus all of Pixi's soothing/hydrating actives (licorice, centella, hyaluronic acid).

Only shares salicylic acid in a fragranced, alcohol-based toner built around thyme oil and menthol, missing glycolic acid, hyaluronic acid, and all the soothing extracts from the source.

This is a fragranced witch hazel/lotus toner with only trace lactic and citric acid, no salicylic acid, no glycolic acid at a real dose, and none of Pixi's key actives like hyaluronic acid or licorice.