Fat Water Pore-Refining Toner Serum

Shares niacinamide as the hero active, but swaps out kahai oil and cactus flower extract for witch hazel, green tea, and ceramide NP, giving a different skin-feel and secondary benefit profile.

Matches on niacinamide but the supporting actives are entirely different (hyaluronic acid, green tea, bitter cherry extract vs kahai oil and cactus flower extract), so hydration mechanism and texture will differ.

Contains niacinamide as a shared active, but it's diluted in a long list of humectants and rice-based extracts that don't replicate the kahai oil or cactus flower extract benefits.

This is a surfactant-based cleansing tonic (sulfates, cocamidopropyl betaine) with niacinamide as a minor addition, not a pore-refining serum-toner, so the format and purpose don't match despite the shared active.

Niacinamide appears far down the ingredient list behind alcohol denat and other actives like caffeine and zinc, making this a different-purpose toner (astringent/sebum-control) that doesn't replicate the Fenty formula's key actives.