Rice Water & Niacinamide 3% Toner

Both contain niacinamide as a hero active, but this lacks the rice extract/rice ferment complex and the Plum toner's percentage (3%) isn't confirmed here, plus it adds hyaluronic acid instead.

Shares niacinamide but swaps the rice water/rice ferment base for witch hazel and adds ceramides, giving a different overall formula focus (pore-refining vs rice hydration).

Only real overlap is niacinamide; the rest of the formula (kahai oil, cactus flower extract) has nothing to do with the rice water/ferment complex that defines the source product.

Contains niacinamide plus panthenol and sodium gluconate like the source, but includes alcohol denat and lacks any rice-derived ingredients, making it a different type of toner (astringent-leaning vs hydrating).

Niacinamide appears far down the list at likely trace strength alongside dozens of unrelated actives (algae, peptides, oils), so this is a totally different luxury formula, not a niacinamide/rice water toner dupe.